Eugen Sarbu, attorney-at-law
In construction works contracts concluded pursuant to Government Decision No. 1/2018 (“GD No. 1/2018”), delays may affect both the completion date and the costs incurred by the Contractor. Although these two consequences often arise from the same event, entitlement to an extension of time for completion and entitlement to financial compensation are distinct components of a contractual claim and must be substantiated separately.
The General and Particular Conditions of Contract approved by GD No. 1/2018 establish a formal mechanism for the notification, substantiation and determination of claims. This mechanism is intended to identify the event giving rise to the claim, verify its contractual basis, assess its impact on the programme and, where applicable, determine the additional costs incurred. It bears similarities to the mechanisms found in FIDIC contracts, particularly with regard to the notification of claims and the obligation to provide supporting documentation. However, the applicable time limits and the consequences of non-compliance must be assessed by reference to the relevant form of contract.
In practice, the success of an extension-of-time claim depends not only on the occurrence of an event affecting the works, but also on compliance with the contractual procedure, proof of causation and separate quantification of the effects on time and costs.
I. Circumstances That May Justify an Extension of Time for Completion
1. Employer’s Risks
A starting point when assessing entitlement to an extension of time is Sub-Clause 68.1 of the Conditions of Contract, which identifies the circumstances classified as Employer’s Risks. Under Sub-Clause 68.2, where such a risk causes delay or additional costs, the Contractor may be entitled—subject to the claims procedure under Sub-Clause 69a and unless the contract provides otherwise—to an extension of time for completion and, where applicable, payment of additional costs.
The list of Employer’s Risks covers a range of circumstances that must be assessed in light of the specific facts and their actual effects on the execution of the works:
- Administrative Orders issued by the Supervisor. The issuance of an Administrative Order in breach of the contractual requirements, or its delayed issuance, may constitute a relevant risk if it affects the progress of the works and the applicable contractual conditions are met.
- Access to the Site. Failure to provide access to the Site, or a delay in doing so, may prevent planned activities from commencing or continuing.
- Errors in topographical benchmarks and reference systems. This category covers errors that a diligent Contractor could not reasonably have identified and avoided in a manner that would have prevented delays or additional costs.
- Errors or deficiencies in the Employer’s Requirements or contractual documents. Inaccuracies, omissions or incomplete documentation may result in additional activities, changes to the construction methodology or delays.
- Unforeseeable physical conditions. This category includes natural or artificial conditions that could not reasonably have been foreseen, such as unexploded ordnance, utilities, obstructions or pollutants, subject to the exclusions expressly provided for in the contract, including those relating to exceptionally adverse weather conditions.
- Unforeseeable archaeological discoveries. Such discoveries may restrict access to working areas and affect the sequencing of activities.
- Delays or irregularities in testing. Delays in, or improper performance of, tests by the Employer or the Supervisor may impede the progress of the works.
- Suspension of the works. A suspension instructed by the Supervisor for reasons not attributable to the Contractor may affect both the completion period and costs.
- Early use of parts of the Works. The use of parts of the Works before Taking-Over, in circumstances other than those permitted by the contract, may constitute a relevant risk.
- Omission of works from the scope of the contract. Changes to the scope may affect the organisation and planning of the works.
- Changes in legislation after the Reference Date and force majeure, subject to the conditions and consequences set out in the contract.
This list should not be interpreted as guaranteeing that every event falling within one of these categories will automatically entitle the Contractor to an extension of time. The Contractor must identify the applicable contractual provision and demonstrate the event’s actual effect on the completion date. The mere existence of a circumstance that can be classified as an Employer’s Risk does not replace the need to establish causation and assess the impact on the programme.
It is also necessary to verify whether the event is governed by a specific clause that establishes different conditions or consequences. Sub-Clause 68.2 refers to the claims procedure and the applicable contractual provisions; accordingly, the analysis must be systematic and should not rely solely on the list of Employer’s Risks.
2. Extension of Time under the Contractual Provisions Governing Time for Completion
Clause 35, which addresses extensions of time for completion, must be considered together with the provisions governing Employer’s Risks and the claims mechanism under Clause 69. Depending on the event and the applicable form of contract, entitlement to an extension may require the Contractor to demonstrate that an event for which it is not responsible has affected the completion date.
The assessment should focus on three main elements:
- The event giving rise to the claim and its contractual basis: what happened, when it happened and which contractual provisions entitle the Contractor to seek an extension.
- Causation: how the event affected the activities included in the programme and whether it caused a delay relevant to completion of the Works.
- The extension sought: the period of extension justified by the demonstrated impact, taking into account the programme and the actual progress of the works.
The programme and its updates are therefore important tools in substantiating a claim. A general description of the delay is insufficient if it does not identify the affected activities and explain how they influenced the completion date.
It is equally important to distinguish events that justify an extension from circumstances in which the Contractor bears the consequences of its own planning, insufficient mobilisation or other matters falling within its sphere of responsibility. Contractual classification and causation analysis are essential to establishing entitlement to an extension.
3. Extension of Time and Financial Compensation Are Distinct Entitlements
An event may justify an extension of time without making all costs claimed by the Contractor automatically recoverable. Conversely, the existence of additional expenditure does not, in itself, establish that the completion date should be extended.
Under Sub-Clause 68.2, entitlement to an extension and entitlement to additional costs must be assessed by reference to the effects of the event and the applicable contractual conditions. For the cases expressly specified in the contract, the clause also provides for a 2% profit margin on the relevant additional costs, or a lower percentage if expressly stated in the tender. This provision should not be treated as a general rule applicable to every claim for costs.
Accordingly, a properly substantiated claim should set out the impact on time and the financial impact separately, identify the contractual basis for each component and avoid treating an extension of time as automatically entitling the Contractor to financial compensation.
II. The Claims Procedure
1. Notice of Claim — Sub-Clause 69a.1
The first step is for the Contractor to submit a Notice of Claim. Under Sub-Clause 69a.1, the notice must be submitted within 30 days of the occurrence of the event or circumstance giving rise to the claim.
The notice should make the claim identifiable and should, in essence, include:
- a reference to the contractual provision governing the notice;
- identification of the sub-clauses on which the claim is based;
- a brief description of the event or circumstance giving rise to the claim; and
- the date on which the event occurred.
At this stage, the notice should not be confused with the fully detailed claim. Its purpose is to clearly identify the Contractor’s intention to pursue a claim and the event on which it is based. A simple notification of a problem arising on Site may be insufficient if it does not indicate an intention to seek an extension of time and/or financial compensation.
Compliance with the 30-day time limit is particularly important. Sub-Clause 69a.1(3) provides that, if the notice is not submitted within the prescribed period, the Contractor will not be entitled to an extension of time or financial compensation for the consequences of the event attributable to the period before the date falling 30 days prior to the notice. The precise effect of a late notice must be determined by applying the contractual wording to the circumstances of the case.
In practice, it is prudent to submit the notice promptly after identifying the event, even if its full impact on time or costs cannot yet be determined.
2. Detailed Claim — Sub-Clause 69a.2
Following the notice, the Contractor must submit the Detailed Claim within 30 days of the Notice of Claim. An extension of this period is possible only at the Contractor’s request and with the Supervisor’s consent. Under the contractual provisions, late submission must be justified by the inability to provide the details within the prescribed period for reasons outside the Contractor’s control and not attributable to circumstances for which it is responsible.
Failure to meet the deadline may result in the loss of entitlement to an extension of time and financial compensation in respect of the relevant event. Where an extension of the submission deadline is necessary, the request should therefore be made and justified in good time.
The Detailed Claim must be sufficiently clear and comprehensive to allow assessment by a person who was not directly involved in the performance of the contract. To that end, it should include:
- Contractual basis: identification of the clauses and sub-clauses supporting the entitlements claimed.
- Statement of facts: a description of the event, its chronology and its consequences for the execution of the works.
- Time-impact analysis: an explanation of the affected activities and a revised programme, in accordance with Sub-Clause 17 where applicable, if an extension of time is sought.
- Cost quantification: a separate and detailed presentation of each category of costs for which compensation is claimed.
- Supporting records: daily records, contractual correspondence, Site reports, statements of work performed, accounting documents and other relevant evidence demonstrating the event and its effects.
Where claims relating to several events are combined, each event should be identified individually, and its time and financial impact should be presented separately. A global claim that combines different events without distinguishing their respective effects may make it more difficult to verify causation and the amount claimed.
In particular, Sub-Clause 69a.2 requires financial compensation claims and their cost categories to be presented separately and in detail. Failure to comply with this requirement may result in rejection of the claim under the contractual mechanism.
3. The Supervisor’s Review and Determination of the Claim
Under Sub-Clause 69c.1, after receiving the final details of the claim, the Supervisor verifies compliance with the procedural requirements and whether a contractual basis exists for the request. Within the period prescribed by the contract, the Supervisor either admits the claim in principle or rejects it with reasons.
Admission in principle should not be confused with automatic recognition of the entire extension or all costs claimed. It marks the beginning of the subsequent stage of assessment and determination.
Sub-Clause 69c.2 governs the consultation stage and the issuance of the Supervisor’s decision. Under the mechanism described in the Conditions of Contract, the consultation period is 15 days, and the decision must be issued within the applicable contractual period. The decision must be reasoned and must distinguish between the impact on the time for completion and any financial compensation due.
The parties must closely monitor procedural deadlines and the consequences of failing to challenge a decision. In the cases specified by the contract, a dissatisfied party may be required to submit a Notice of Dissatisfaction (“NOD”) within 10 days. If no notice is submitted within the prescribed period, the decision may become final and binding on the parties. The contract also addresses the consequences of the Supervisor’s failure to issue a decision within the applicable time limit.
These deadlines must be checked in each case against the relevant procedural circumstances and the applicable version of the contract. Claims management does not end when the supporting documentation is submitted: monitoring responses, challenge deadlines and obligations arising from the decision is equally important.
III. Costs Associated with an Extension of Time for Completion
1. Contractual Framework and Assessment Principles
Specialist literature on extension-of-time claims in construction contracts, including FIDIC contracts, similarly identifies Site overheads, costs associated with personnel and equipment retained for a longer period, head-office overheads and financing costs as relevant categories.
An extension of time does not, in itself, justify recovery of all the Contractor’s overheads. It is necessary to identify costs that would not have been incurred to the same extent had the event not occurred and to avoid counting the same expenditure twice under different categories.
2. Main Categories of Costs
a. Additional direct costs of executing the Works
These may include additional expenditure directly caused by the event and required to continue, protect or reorganise the works. Depending on the circumstances, relevant items may include additional handling, storage or relocation of materials, extra transport, protection and preservation measures, temporary works, or additional mobilisation and demobilisation. Under design-and-build contracts, certain additional design costs may also be relevant where they are contractually justified and causally linked to the event.
b. Site overheads
This category covers the costs of maintaining the Site organisation during the extended period. Examples may include Site management and administrative staff, offices and storage containers, utilities, security, cleaning, maintenance and other ancillary services. Costs must be linked to the actual extension period and to the resources that remained necessary for the project. The mere existence of a monthly Site overhead budget is insufficient; the additional component attributable to the event must be substantiated.
c. Personnel and human resources
Retaining technical, coordination and administrative personnel for a longer period may generate additional costs. Depending on the available records and the contractual provisions, these may include salaries and related employer contributions for additional personnel, overtime or additional shifts, as well as certain transport, accommodation or allowance expenses associated with extended deployment. It is necessary to distinguish genuinely additional costs from expenditure that would have been incurred in any event under the contract.
d. Plant, equipment and installations
An extension may lead to additional costs for hiring plant, retaining equipment on Site or keeping equipment idle. Relevant items may include hire charges for the extended period, operator costs, maintenance, technical inspections, repairs and additional mobilisation or demobilisation costs. For Contractor-owned equipment, any recovery of usage or depreciation costs must be supported by a consistent calculation methodology and documentary evidence; the equipment’s accounting value alone does not automatically establish a recoverable additional cost.
e. Head-office overheads
An extended contract period may require head-office administrative resources to remain allocated to project management for longer. Coordination and administration costs, support personnel and other overheads may be considered where there is a justified allocation methodology and a demonstrable link to the extension. Recovery should not be based solely on applying a generic percentage to the contract value. The calculation should explain the allocation basis, the relevant period and how the amount claimed reflects the effect of the event, without overlapping with other claimed costs.
f. Insurance, bonds and financing costs
An extension of the execution period may require insurance policies or contractual guarantees to be extended, potentially generating additional premiums and fees. Depending on the contractual basis and the supporting evidence, certain financing costs, interest or bank charges associated with the extended period may also be considered. These items must be identified individually, quantified and linked to the period in which they were actually incurred; not every financial cost incurred by the Contractor can be passed on to the Employer.
g. Profit and other financial losses
Sub-Clause 69a.2 includes, within the category of other costs and losses, examples such as financial obligations and loss of profit. Separately, Sub-Clause 68.2 provides, for cases expressly specified in the contract, for a 2% profit margin on the relevant additional costs or the lower percentage expressly stated in the tender. These two aspects should not be conflated: the percentage provided for under Sub-Clause 68.2 does not create an automatic entitlement to profit in every extension-of-time claim, while a separate claim for loss of profit requires its own contractual basis and supporting justification.
3. Evidence and Quantification of Costs
In practice, the difference between a plausible claim and one that can be verified contractually often lies in the quality of the supporting evidence. Sub-Clause 69a.2 requires the Detailed Claim and relevant supporting documents to be provided, including daily records. This approach is consistent with the importance attached by FIDIC contracts and related literature to records made contemporaneously with the event (“contemporary records”).
For each cost category, the supporting file should allow the reviewer to verify: (i) the event that generated the cost; (ii) the affected period; (iii) the resources and expenditure involved; (iv) the calculation method; and (v) the link between the amount claimed and the effect of the event. Relevant documents may include daily Site reports, programmes and updates, correspondence with the Employer and the Supervisor, timesheets, equipment logs, hire agreements, invoices, payment records and calculations allocating overheads.
It should also be borne in mind that an invoice or accounting entry does not, by itself, demonstrate that the amount is attributable to the event being claimed. The cost assessment should distinguish genuinely additional expenditure from the ordinary costs of performing the contract, avoidable costs from unavoidable costs, and periods during which resources were affected by the event from periods in which other causes intervened.
Conclusions
Obtaining an extension of time under contracts governed by GD No. 1/2018 requires more than identifying a delay. The Contractor must establish the contractual basis of the claim, comply with the notice and substantiation deadlines, demonstrate the impact on the programme and separately present any financial compensation sought.
As regards costs, Sub-Clause 69a.2 provides a framework for classifying claims, including costs associated with design and execution, Site overheads, and other costs and losses, such as head-office overheads and financial obligations. Practice and specialist literature concerning FIDIC contracts may offer useful guidance on identifying and documenting these categories. However, entitlement to recovery must always be assessed against the specific contract.
An effective claim is therefore one that is submitted on time, structured by individual events and cost categories, supported by contemporaneous records and based on a clear demonstration of the link between the event, the delay and the additional costs claimed.
